Cnidaria — Anemones, Jellies and Corals
Build a paper gut and measure what folding does to it. Find out what really makes an anemone sting — touch, taste, or both. Draw the jelly's double life and sort a dozen animals into their classes. Then answer the booklet's own questions, including the one this course has been waiting for since Topic 22.
Investigations column, block 26: "Photographs, slide show and videos · Observation of as many live species as possible · Use a specific locally available example · THEME — Increasing surface area. Prepare cardboard cylinders from an A4 sheet (landscape format). Now have the pupils fold A4 paper sheets to corrugate them and see how many can be fitted around the inside of the cylinder." And for the classes: "Study live examples (aquarium or rock-pool study) · use a specific locally available example, but ensure ability to recognise major sub-groups or classes and defining characteristics · incorporate into ecosystem field trips."
The surface-area theme is Investigation 1. The rock-pool study, with the sandy anemone as the local example, is Investigation 2. Recognising the classes is Investigation 3, and Investigation 4 is the booklet's "Test your knowledge" questions.
What you need
- 🟢 kitchen Five or six sheets of A4 paper (or thin card for the cylinder), sticky tape, a ruler and a pencil
- 🟢 kitchen A calculator, graph paper, and coloured pencils
- 🌊 shore A rock pool with anemones at low tide — Cape Recife, Sardinia Bay or any rocky shore
- 🟢 kitchen For the shore: two thin twigs or wooden skewers, a mussel (from the shop, or one already broken open on the shore), a small jar, a stopwatch or phone, and a notebook
- 🟡 optional A hand lens, to see the knobs on a sandy anemone's column and the tiny polyps of a hydroid
Investigation 1 needs only paper, and it has supplied results to check yours against. Investigation 2 gives you a full set of results from five anemones to analyse. Investigations 3 and 4 are desk tasks with everything supplied.
Aim
To find out how much extra surface folds can pack into the same space — the reason an anemone's endoderm is pleated into many folds.
Method
- Roll one A4 sheet into a tube the long way, so that the 29.7 cm edge goes round and the tube is 21 cm tall. Butt the edges together (do not overlap them) and tape the seam. This is the plain "gut".
- Take another sheet and fold it like a fan — a concertina — with folds 2 cm apart, running parallel to the short edge, so each pleat is 21 cm long.
- Squeeze the folded sheet together and stand it inside the tube against the wall, with its pleats running from top to bottom. Add more folded sheets the same way, side by side around the inside, until no more will fit without crushing. Count the sheets.
- Take them out. Repeat with sheets folded every 1 cm, and then every 0.5 cm.
Supplied results — one learner's three trials
| Fold spacing | Sheets that fitted | How far the pleats stood in from the wall |
|---|---|---|
| no lining (plain tube) | 0 | — |
| 2 cm | 2 | about 1.8 cm |
| 1 cm | 3 | about 0.9 cm |
| 0.5 cm | 4 | about 0.5 cm |
The learner noted: "With 2 cm folds the deep pleats from the two sheets met in the middle of the tube and a third would not go in. The 0.5 cm sheets lay much flatter against the wall, so more fitted — but they were fiddly to fold."
Results
| Fold spacing | Sheets fitted | Surface inside (cm²) | Times the plain tube |
|---|---|---|---|
| plain tube | 0 | 623.7 | 1 |
| 2 cm | |||
| 1 cm | |||
| 0.5 cm |
Analysis
- Show that the inside surface of the plain tube is 623.7 cm². 2
- Calculate the tube's radius from its circumference, and then its volume. 3
- Complete Table 1.1 — your own results or the supplied ones — showing one calculation in full. 6
- Draw a bar graph of the surface inside the tube against the fold spacing, including the plain tube. 4
- Describe the trend, and explain why finer folds let more surface fit into the tube. 3
- The paper takes up almost no room, so the tube's volume hardly changes. Calculate the surface-area-to-volume ratio of the plain tube and of the tube lined with 0.5 cm folds, and explain what this means for an animal that digests its food on its inner surface. 4
- Say what each part of the model represents in a sea anemone: the tube, the corrugated sheets, and the space in the middle. 3
- Give two ways in which the paper model is unlike a real anemone. 2
- An anemone cannot simply grow fatter to get more digestive surface. Use what you know about diffusion to explain why folding is the better solution. 2
Aim
To find out whether touch, the taste of food, or both together make an anemone's tentacles grab — and to watch it swallow.
Method
- At low tide, find five anemones of the same kind, fully open, underwater in pools. Sandy anemones — with sand and shell grit stuck to the column — are ideal. Label them A to E in your notebook.
- Crush a little mussel flesh in a jar of sea water to make mussel juice. Keep one twig clean.
- Give each anemone four stimuli, five minutes apart, in this order: ① touch the tentacles gently with the clean twig; ② let a few drops of mussel juice drift over the tentacles without touching them; ③ touch the tentacles with a twig dipped in mussel juice; ④ drop a piece of mussel the size of a pea onto the tentacles.
- Score each response from 0 to 3 using the key below. For stimulus ④, time how long it takes from the first touch until the mussel has disappeared into the mouth.
Supplied results — five sandy anemones in a Cape Recife rock pool
| Stimulus | A | B | C | D | E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ① clean twig | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| ② juice only, no touch | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| ③ twig dipped in juice | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| ④ piece of mussel | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| A | B | C | D | E |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 42 | 55 | 38 | 61 | 47 |
Notes from the notebook. (a) With juice only, the tentacles of A, B, D and E waved slightly and stretched a little longer, but did not curl. (b) Anemone A was then touched five more times with the clean twig, a minute apart; its scores were 1, 1, 0, 0, 0. (c) When the mussel reached the mouth, the mouth opened, the piece slid in, and the mouth closed behind it; the anemone stayed fully expanded. (d) Anemone C was accidentally touched on its column. It pulled in its tentacles, squirted a jet of water from its mouth and shrank to a sandy lump about half its height; it took about fifteen minutes to open again.
Analysis
- Calculate the mean score for each of the four stimuli. 4
- Draw a bar graph of the mean score for each stimulus. 4
- Compare the responses to stimuli ①, ② and ③. What do they show about what triggers the anemone's stinging cells? 3
- Name the independent and dependent variables in this investigation, and give two variables that were controlled. 4
- Why was each stimulus tested on five anemones, rather than one? 2
- Calculate the mean and the range of the swallowing times. 3
- Note (c) says the anemone stayed fully expanded while it swallowed. Use the pharynx to explain how it swallows without losing the water in its coelenteron — and why that matters. 3
- Note (b): suggest two explanations for anemone A's falling response to the clean twig. 2
- Note (d): explain how anemone C shrank, and why it took so long to open again. 3
- Give two reasons why this investigation used a twig and small pieces of mussel, and never fingers or bluebottles. 2
Aim
To draw the life cycle of a jelly, and to recognise the classes of cnidarians — and a look-alike — from descriptions of real animals.
Your diagram
Twelve animals
Each was seen on a South African shore, dive or aquarium visit.
Results
| Animal | Common name | Phylum | Class (and division, for Anthozoa) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 5 | |||
| 6 | |||
| 7 | |||
| 8 | |||
| 9 | |||
| 10 | |||
| 11 | |||
| 12 |
Analysis
- Draw the life cycle of a scyphozoan jelly as a labelled cycle of six stages — medusa, gametes, planula larva, polyp (scyphistoma), strobila, ephyra. Show which part of the cycle is sexual and which is asexual. 8
- The booklet calls the scyphistoma a "larva". Explain why "polyp" describes it better, and name the true larva in the cycle. 3
- Complete Table 3.1. (One mark for each correct class or division; common names and phyla are not marked, but help you.) 12
- One of the twelve is not a cnidarian at all. Which one? Give two pieces of evidence from its description. 3
- Animal 1 is called a polymorphic colony. Explain both words using its description. 2
- Animals 7 and 9 have algae living in their cells; animal 10 has none. Use this to explain why reef-building corals are found only in shallow, clear water, while sea fans can live at 40 m or deeper. 3
Aim
To answer the booklet's own questions — the ones most like an exam — and to settle where a coral's algae live.
Your diagrams
Analysis
- Give the scientific term for each of the following: (a) the cnidarian body form typified by a jelly(fish); (b) describes an animal with a body wall made up of two tissue layers; (c) the stinging cells of cnidarians; (d) an organism which stays attached to a substrate and moves about very little, if at all; (e) the microscopic mutualistic algae which inhabit the endodermal cells of coral polyps; (f) muscle groups performing opposite actions. 6
- Use the lettered body-wall diagram — in your booklet (question 2) or the explorer on the topic page (name each letter before you tap it) — and write down the labels for A to H. 8
- Give the function of each of A, D and E, and a general function for the body layer F. 4
- Give one similarity and two differences between animals of the phyla Cnidaria and Ctenophora. 3
- Write a short paragraph, with about eight points, describing how an anemone catches and ingests a shrimp. 8
- You must brief a scuba-diving class on recognising soft corals, hard corals and sea fans before a tropical dive. They already know what sea anemones are. Prepare a point-form list under the headings: (a) colonial polyps; (b) simple line diagrams showing the shape or structure of each type; (c) how each of the three groups supports itself. 12
- Where do the algae live? In Topic 22 your sources said zooxanthellae live in a coral polyp's ectoderm. This topic's booklet text and definition say endodermal cells — but its own question 1.5 says "ectodermal". (a) Which is correct? (b) Give one reason why that layer is a sensible place for the algae to live. (c) The booklet also says the algae give the coral "minerals, like calcium carbonate". Correct this statement. 4
Memo — worked answers and mark allocation (does not print)
Total: 135 marks — Investigation 1: 29 · Investigation 2: 30 · Investigation 3: 31 · Investigation 4: 45.
Investigation 1 — folds and surface area
- Q1 (2): The inside of the tube is the A4 sheet itself: 29.7 cm × 21 cm (1) = 623.7 cm² (1).
- Q2 (3): r = 29.7 ÷ (2 × 3.14) = 4.73 cm (1). V = 3.14 × 4.73² × 21 (1) = about 1 475 cm³ (1). Accept 1 470–1 480 cm³ (rounding).
- Q3 (6): Each sheet adds 2 × 623.7 = 1 247.4 cm² (shown in full, 1). 2 cm: 2 sheets → 2 494.8 cm², 4 × the plain tube (2 for row). 1 cm: 3 sheets → 3 742.2 cm², 6 × (1 for row, 1 for ratio). 0.5 cm: 4 sheets → 4 989.6 cm², 8 × (1). Accept the learner's own correctly calculated results.
- Q4 (4): Bars for all four (plain, 2, 1, 0.5 cm) (1); axes labelled with units, "surface inside (cm²)" and "fold spacing" (1); a sensible, even scale (1); bars accurately plotted (1).
- Q5 (3): The finer the folds, the more surface fits inside the same tube (1). Finer pleats are shallower and lie flatter, so they take less room (1); more sheets fit side by side, and every sheet adds two faces of surface (1).
- Q6 (4): Plain: 623.7 ÷ 1 475 = 0.42 per cm (1). Lined with 0.5 cm folds: 4 989.6 ÷ 1 475 = 3.38 per cm (1) — eight times as much surface for the same volume (1). An animal that digests on its inner surface gets far more digestive cells, so it digests and absorbs food faster without becoming any bigger (1).
- Q7 (3): Tube = the body wall / column (1); corrugated sheets = the folds of the endoderm, lined with digestive cells (1); the space in the middle = the coelenteron (1).
- Q8 (2): Any two: the anemone's folds are living cells, not paper; the folds (mesenteries) run inward from the wall towards the pharynx, not around the wall; the real folds are moist and bathed in fluid; an anemone can change shape, the tube cannot; real folds also carry muscles and make gametes; the model has no mouth or pharynx.
- Q9 (2): Growing fatter adds volume faster than surface, and the cells deep in a thick body would be too far from water for diffusion to supply them (1); folding adds surface while every layer stays thin and close to water (1).
Investigation 2 — what makes an anemone sting?
- Q10 (4): ① clean twig 3 ÷ 5 = 0.6; ② juice only 4 ÷ 5 = 0.8; ③ twig with juice 13 ÷ 5 = 2.6; ④ mussel 15 ÷ 5 = 3.0 (1 each).
- Q11 (4): Four bars, correctly labelled (1); axes labelled — "mean response score (0–3)" and "stimulus" (1); a sensible scale from 0 to 3 (1); accurate plotting (1).
- Q12 (3): Touch alone (0.6) and taste alone (0.8) each gave only a weak response (1), but touch together with the chemical of food gave a strong one (2.6) (1). So the stinging cells fire most strongly when both contact and a chemical signal of prey are present — the trigger needs both (1).
- Q13 (4): Independent: the type of stimulus (1). Dependent: the response score (1). Controlled — any two: the same kind of anemone; all fully open and underwater; the same twig and juice; the same time between stimuli; the same pool, tide and time of day; the same person scoring (2).
- Q14 (2): Anemones vary — one could be fed, damaged or unusual (1); repeating with five and taking a mean makes the results more reliable (1).
- Q15 (3): Mean = 243 ÷ 5 = 48.6 s (2). Range = 61 − 38 = 23 s (1).
- Q16 (3): The muscular pharynx opens at its top to take in the food and closes behind it, then opens at its lower end to let the food into the coelenteron (1), so the mouth and pharynx are never open all the way through at once and the water is not lost (1). That water is the anemone's hydrostatic skeleton — losing it would collapse the body (1).
- Q17 (2): Any two: the anemone habituated — it learned to ignore a harmless, repeated touch with no food; the nematocysts in that patch had already fired and had not yet been replaced by the interstitial cells; the anemone was now fed and less responsive; it was tired or stressed by repeated handling.
- Q18 (3): The longitudinal muscles contracted and pulled the anemone down (1); it opened its mouth and expelled the water from its coelenteron, so its hydrostatic skeleton collapsed (1). To open again it had to slowly refill the coelenteron with water, using cilia in the pharynx, before it could expand (1).
- Q19 (2): Any two: fingers could be stung — and some people react badly; bluebottles and jellies sting painfully even when stranded; a twig gives the same light touch every time (fair test); small scraps feed the anemone without harming it or wasting animals; pulling or over-handling anemones damages them.
Investigation 3 — life cycles and classes
- Q20 (8): Six stages drawn and named in the correct order, joined into a cycle by arrows: medusa → gametes (eggs and sperm, fertilisation) → planula larva → polyp / scyphistoma → strobila (stack of discs) → ephyra → back to medusa (6: one per stage in the correct position). The medusa-to-planula half labelled sexual (1) and the polyp-to-ephyra half labelled asexual (1).
- Q21 (3): The scyphistoma is attached, feeds with tentacles and has the full polyp body plan, so it is a small polyp (1) — it even buds and lives for years (1). The true larva is the ciliated, free-swimming planula (1). (Accept the ephyra as a "larval" medusa, as the booklet calls it.)
- Q22 (12): One mark each. 1 bluebottle — Hydrozoa (a polymorphic colony). 2 hydroid — Hydrozoa. 3 compass jelly — Scyphozoa. 4 box jelly — Cubozoa. 5 sandy anemone — Anthozoa: anemones. 6 strawberry anemones — Anthozoa: colonial anemones. 7 zoanthids — Anthozoa: zoanthids. 8 soft coral — Anthozoa: soft corals. 9 hard coral — Anthozoa: hard corals. 10 sea fan — Anthozoa: sea fans. 11 comb jelly — not a cnidarian; phylum Ctenophora. 12 by-the-wind sailor (Velella) — Hydrozoa (accept any answer that recognises it as a hydrozoan colony like the bluebottle).
- Q23 (3): Number 11, the comb jelly (1). Any two: no stinging cells; prey sticks to sticky cells on its tentacles; it moves with eight rows of beating plates (combs of cilia), not by pulsing a bell (2).
- Q24 (2): Colony: what looks like one animal is made of many individuals joined together (1). Polymorphic: the individuals have different body forms for different jobs — the float, stinging tentacles, feeding parts and reproductive parts (1).
- Q25 (3): The algae in hard corals photosynthesise and supply most of the coral's food (1), so reef-building corals must live where enough sunlight reaches them — shallow, clear water (1). Sea fans have no zooxanthellae and feed by catching plankton, so they do not need light and can live at great depths (1).
Investigation 4 — the booklet's questions
- Q26 (6): (a) medusa · (b) diploblastic · (c) nematocysts · (d) sessile · (e) zooxanthellae · (f) antagonistic.
- Q27 (8): A nematocyst · B longitudinal muscle band · C interstitial cells · D amoeboid nutritive-epithelial (musculo-digestive) cell · E nerve cell · F ectoderm · G mesoglea · H endoderm.
- Q28 (4): A — to capture prey: it fires a barbed thread that pierces and injects venom, or a sticky thread that entangles (1). D — internal (intracellular) digestion: it engulfs food particles into food vacuoles and digests them (1). E — coordination: it carries signals through the nerve net between sensory cells and muscle fibres (1). F — protection and capturing food (1).
- Q29 (3): Similarity (1) — any one: both have jelly-like bodies; both have an ectoderm, a mesoglea and an endoderm-lined coelenteron; both are radially symmetrical; most have tentacles for catching food. Differences (2) — any two: ctenophores have no nematocysts (sticky cells instead); they swim with eight rows of comb-like cilia, cnidarians by muscles; most ctenophores have anal pores as well as a mouth; ctenophores have no polyp stage.
- Q30 (8): One mark per point, in a paragraph: sensory cells detect the shrimp's movement or chemicals · the tentacles may reach towards it · on contact the nematocysts fire · barbed threads inject venom while sticky threads entangle it · the shrimp is held and paralysed or killed · the tentacles push it into the mouth · the pharynx swallows it in two steps without losing the water in the coelenteron · gland cells release enzymes and digestion begins in the coelenteron (external), finishing in food vacuoles in the digestive cells (internal) · nutrients spread by diffusion · undigested remains are pushed back out of the mouth. (Any eight.)
- Q31 (12): (a) Colonial polyps (3): all three are colonies of many polyps joined together by a coenenchyme or a shared base (1); each polyp is like a small anemone with a ring of tentacles round its mouth (1); soft coral — polyps grow from one fleshy base; hard coral — each polyp in its own limestone cup; sea fan — polyps along a branching, fan-shaped frame (1). (b) Line diagrams (6): two marks each — a lobed or branching soft colony with polyps on its surface; a hard, branching or rounded colony showing polyps in cups; a flat, branching fan with a central rod and polyps along the branches. (c) Support (3): soft coral — hydrostatic: the two body layers, mesoglea and water-filled coelenterons (accept also tiny chalky spicules, sclerites, in the tissue) (1); hard coral — a skeleton of calcium carbonate cups, built by the polyps (1); sea fan — a stiff but flexible central rod of the horn-like protein gorgonin (1).
- Q32 (4): (a) Endodermal — the algae live in the inner layer (the gastrodermis) lining the coelenteron; the booklet's text and examinable definition are right and its question 1.5 is a slip (1). (b) Any one: it is next to the coelenteron, where the polyp's carbon dioxide and nitrogen-rich wastes collect, which the algae use; the algae are sheltered inside the polyp from grazers and waves (1). (c) The algae do not supply calcium carbonate — the coral builds its own skeleton (1); the algae supply sugars from photosynthesis that power the building, and remove CO₂, so corals with algae build their skeletons much faster in light (1).
Marking note. Q32 closes a loop that opened in Topic 22: two parts of this course's own sources disagreed about where a coral's algae live. A learner who can say which is right, why the layer makes sense, and what the algae really give the coral has done what scientists do with conflicting sources. In Q26(e), the booklet's original question 1.5 says "ectodermal"; the term asked for is "zooxanthellae" either way.